Comment on 24C3 talk "Hacking ideologies, part 2: Open Source, a capitalist movement"

Ideologies, like other religion-like entities are not discussible. Therefore such talks should not point out the personal opinion but reflect the problems of certain ideologies -- in this case of the socialistic and capitalistic ideology. But you have not mentioned any particular problems. Being profit oriented is not a problem but an essential consequence of competitive economical systems. Being "evil" is not a problem but the subjective view on the consequence of being competitive. Also the economical growth must not be necessarily a problem. A problem I would like to be discussed is whether OSS is a product of a capitalistic economic system and whether OSS as it is known could be evolved in an economical system where every important program would be the property of the state -- but, only the closed source property of the state (and therefore everybody). The problem: The necessity of open public property in an economical system based on collective property.

Comments

Popular posts from this blog

Tuning ext4 for performance with emphasis on SSD usage

NetBeans 6.1: Working with Google´s Android SDK, Groovy and Grails